Pothole Caused Car Accident In Michigan: Who Is Liable?

In Michigan, liability for a pothole caused car accident depends on who had legal jurisdiction over the roadway, whether strict statutory notice rules were met, and whether the state’s governmental immunity exceptions apply, which makes these cases highly technical and evidence-driven.

Pothole car accident claims in Michigan involve distinct legal rules governing post-crash conduct, governmental liability, available compensation under the No-Fault and tort systems, and strict statutory deadlines. Case outcomes are also influenced by resolution timelines and the factors that determine damages.

A lawyer is often essential in Michigan pothole car accident cases because the legal fight is usually about immunity, jurisdiction, and notice. The right attorney can identify the correct governmental agency, preserve proof before repairs occur, establish notice and causation, and coordinate No-Fault benefits.

If you were injured in a pothole-related car accident, Michigan Auto Law is ready to fight for you. Our attorneys know our state’s statutory requirements, move fast to preserve evidence, and use their specialized experience and skill to get the maximum compensation possible for you. 

What to do after a car accident caused by a pothole in Michigan?

In Michigan, pothole car accidents are time-sensitive because the road can be patched quickly and the most important evidence can disappear overnight. The goal is to lock down proof of the defect, the location, the impact, and the injuries before anyone has a chance to dispute what happened. Here are the most important steps to protect your claim:

• Call police and insist the road defect is documented — Ask the officer to note the defect, the exact location, and how it contributed to the crash.
• Photograph and video the road defect immediately — Get wide-angle shots showing landmarks and close-ups showing depth and damage (a tape measure or shoe for scale helps).
• Capture the exact roadway location — Screenshot GPS coordinates, intersection references, mile markers, and nearby businesses.
• Identify witnesses — Names, phone numbers, and short statements can confirm the road defect existed and was hazardous.
• Preserve your vehicle and damaged parts — Wheels, tires, suspension components, and undercarriage damage can be critical proof of impact force.
• Get medical care right away — Treatment records help establish causation and seriousness.
• Report the defect to the responsible agency — A Michigan pothole car accident case often rises or falls on proving notice, and early reporting matters.
• Contact an experienced lawyer quickly — Government cases have unique rules and strict deadlines that must be handled correctly.

Can I sue if injured in a car accident caused by a pothole in Michigan?

In Michigan, if you are injured in a car accident caused by a pothole, a lawsuit may be possible if certain statutory conditions are met. These cases are not ordinary negligence claims because government agencies responsible for road maintenance may assert protection under our state’s governmental immunity laws act.

Michigan’s governmental immunity statute provides that “a governmental agency is immune from tort liability if the governmental agency is engaged in the exercise or discharge of a governmental function.” (MCL 691.1407(1)). Roadway maintenance is considered a governmental function, which means immunity applies unless a specific statutory exception removes that protection.

The primary statute that allows pothole car accident lawsuits to proceed is Michigan’s highway exception to governmental immunity. Under that exception, “each governmental agency having jurisdiction over a highway shall maintain the highway in reasonable repair so that it is reasonably safe and convenient for public travel.” (MCL 691.1402(1)). In Michigan pothole car accident cases, the legal focus is whether the condition of the roadway failed to meet this statutory standard and whether that failure caused the crash and resulting injuries.

Even when the highway exception applies, state law imposes two strict time requirements:

1. You must be able to prove that the governmental entity either knew about or should have known about the road defect or that the road defect had been there for 30 days or longer – in which case it is presumed that the governmental entity knew about the road defect and had time to repair it. (MCL 691.1403) 
2. Within 120 days of you being injured in an accident caused by a road surface depression, you must serve notice on the responsible governmental entity of your injury and the road defect – which includes the location of the road defect, the injury or injuries you sustained, and the names of any witnesses. (MCL 691.1404(1))

Because both the timing and content of notice are statutory conditions to recovery, failure to comply with these requirements can bar a Michigan pothole car accident claim entirely, regardless of how dangerous the roadway condition was or how serious the injuries may be.

Who is liable for a car accident that was caused by a pothole in Michigan?

Liability for a pothole-related car accident in Michigan depends on which governmental agency had jurisdiction over the roadway where the defect existed. Michigan’s highway exception applies only to “the governmental agency having jurisdiction over a highway,” making jurisdiction the starting point for any liability analysis. (MCL 691.1402(1)).

In practical terms, responsibility for roadway maintenance typically falls on one of several governmental entities, depending on the location and classification of the road. Local streets are often under the control of a city or village, many major roads outside city limits are maintained by county road agencies, and state highways and interstates are generally under the jurisdiction of the State of Michigan. Identifying the correct agency is critical, because statutory notice must be served on the agency with jurisdiction and the lawsuit must be brought against the proper defendant.

This jurisdictional analysis must be considered alongside Michigan’s governmental immunity statute, which begins with broad protection for governmental entities. Under Michigan law, “a governmental agency is immune from tort liability if the governmental agency is engaged in the exercise or discharge of a governmental function.” (MCL 691.1407(1)). Roadway maintenance qualifies as a governmental function, meaning immunity applies unless a statutory exception removes it.

As a result, Michigan pothole-related car accident cases generally require a two-step legal inquiry. The first question is whether the defendant is a governmental agency engaged in a governmental function, in which case immunity applies. The second question is whether the highway exception applies and whether its statutory conditions have been satisfied, because immunity is waived only within the narrow boundaries set by the statute.

What types of compensation are available?

Compensation in a pothole-related car accident case generally falls into two categories under Michigan law: economic damages and noneconomic damages. The availability of each depends on the facts of the case and the applicable legal standards.

• Economic damages – Economic damages include financial losses that can be objectively measured. In Michigan pothole car accident cases, these most commonly include medical expenses and wage loss. Medical damages may include treatment costs, rehabilitation, and related care expenses. Wage loss damages may include income lost due to time away from work as a result of crash-related injuries.
• Noneconomic damages – Noneconomic damages compensate for the human impact of an injury that cannot be measured by bills or receipts. Michigan’s civil jury instructions identify noneconomic damages to include pain and suffering, mental anguish, fright and shock, denial of social pleasure and enjoyment of life, embarrassment, humiliation, and mortification. (M Civ JI 50.02). These damages are intended to account for how an injury affects a person’s daily life, well-being, and ability to enjoy normal activities.

How long do I have to file a lawsuit?

Two separate deadlines control pothole-related car accident cases in Michigan. One governs how long an injured person has to file a lawsuit. The other imposes a mandatory notice requirement that applies specifically to defective highway claims.

For personal injury claims, state law provides a three-year statute of limitations. An action to recover damages for injuries must be filed “within 3 years after the time of the death or injury.” (MCL 600.5805(2)).

Michigan pothole car accident cases are also subject to a separate statutory notice requirement that applies regardless of when a lawsuit is filed. State law states that “as a condition to any recovery for injuries sustained by reason of any defective highway,” the injured person must serve notice on the governmental agency having jurisdiction over the roadway “within 120 days from the time the injury occurred.” (MCL 691.1404(1)). The statute further requires that “the notice shall specify the exact location and nature of the defect, the injury sustained and the names of the witnesses known at the time by the claimant.”

Failure to comply with the 120-day notice requirement can bar recovery entirely, even when a lawsuit is filed within the three-year statute of limitations.

How long do I have to claim No-Fault benefits?

Michigan law imposes a strict one-year deadline for filing a pothole car accident lawsuit to recover No-Fault personal protection insurance benefits after a motor vehicle crash. This deadline applies regardless of fault and controls whether an injured person can pursue unpaid benefits through the courts.

The statute provides that an action for recovery of personal protection insurance benefits payable under this chapter for accidental bodily injury may not be commenced later than 1 year after the date of the crash. (MCL 500.3145(1)). Missing this deadline can permanently bar recovery of No-Fault benefits, even when the insurer should have paid them.

How long does a settlement take?

Michigan pothole accident cases often take longer than typical car crash claims because governmental defendants frequently litigate threshold issues early, including jurisdiction, statutory notice, and whether the roadway defect satisfies the highway exception. How long a case takes to resolve depends on a combination of legal, factual, and evidentiary factors, including the following: 

• Identification of the responsible road agency – Cases move more quickly when jurisdiction is clear early. Delays often occur when multiple agencies dispute responsibility for the roadway.
• Compliance with statutory notice requirements – Timely and complete notice under MCL 691.1404 reduces early dismissal risk. Deficient or disputed notice often leads to motion practice that slows resolution.
• Timing of roadway repair or patching – When a road surface depression is repaired quickly, disputes over defect size, depth, and severity become harder to resolve and may require expert reconstruction.
• Preservation of photographic and physical evidence – Clear photos, measurements, and vehicle damage documentation shorten disputes over causation and defect severity.
• Availability of independent witnesses – Witnesses who can confirm the condition of the roadway and the crash mechanism often accelerate settlement discussions.
• Severity and permanence of injuries – Cases involving minor injuries may resolve sooner, while serious or permanent injuries often require extended medical treatment before valuation is possible.
• Length and complexity of medical treatment – Ongoing treatment, surgeries, or delayed diagnoses can postpone meaningful settlement negotiations.
• Disputes over medical causation – Government defendants frequently challenge whether injuries were caused by the road defect impact, which can require expert opinions and additional discovery.
• Whether the case resolves pre-suit or requires litigation – Some cases resolve before a lawsuit is filed, while others require formal litigation to address immunity and notice defenses.
• Early motion practice by the defense – Motions challenging jurisdiction, immunity, or statutory compliance can pause progress until resolved by the court.
• Court scheduling and docket congestion – The speed of motion hearings and trial dates varies by court and can significantly affect case timelines.
• Willingness of the governmental entity to negotiate – Some agencies take an early resolution approach when liability is clear, while others litigate aggressively regardless of exposure.

When liability is clear, notice is compliant, and injuries are well documented, a Michigan pothole car accident case may resolve within several months. When immunity defenses are disputed or evidence issues arise, resolution often takes a year or longer.

What are the factors that influence the amount awarded?

In Michigan, pothole car accident case value is driven as much by proof and statutory defenses as by the severity of the injuries themselves. Courts and insurers evaluate these cases based on whether the evidence satisfies the legal requirements imposed by state law and whether statutory reductions apply. Key factors include:

• Severity and permanence of the injuries – More serious and permanent injuries generally increase case value, particularly when they affect daily functioning, mobility, or the ability to work.
• Duration and consistency of medical treatment – Continuous, well-documented treatment supports both causation and seriousness, while treatment gaps are often used to challenge injury claims.
• Quality of medical documentation and causation opinions – Clear medical records linking the Michigan car accident injuries to the pothole impact are critical, especially when defendants argue preexisting conditions or alternative causes.
• Proof that the roadway defect was dangerous – Evidence of road surface depression size, depth, location, and surrounding conditions directly affects whether the defect meets the legal standard under the highway exception.
• Evidence connecting the road defect to the crash mechanism – Vehicle damage, photographs, repair records, and expert opinions are often used to establish that the road surface depression actually caused the loss of control or impact.
• Evidence that the defect existed long enough to establish notice – Proof that the road surface depression was present for a sufficient period strengthens the argument that the responsible agency knew or should have known about the defect.
• Compliance with statutory notice requirements – Timely and complete notice under MCL 691.1404 affects whether the case can proceed at all and often influences early settlement posture.
• Availability and credibility of witnesses – Independent witnesses who can confirm the condition of the roadway and the crash circumstances add weight to liability and damages claims.

Do I need a lawyer for a car accident that was caused by a pothole in Michigan?

While a lawyer is not legally mandated, it’s a good idea to have one in a road defect case. Pothole-related car accident claims in Michigan are governed by statutory rules rather than ordinary negligence principles. Governmental immunity, the highway exception, and mandatory notice requirements can defeat otherwise valid claims if not handled correctly.

An experienced lawyer helps manage these statutory requirements from the outset and protects the claim from early dismissal. Key ways a lawyer can help include:

• Identifying the correct road agency with jurisdiction – Liability depends on jurisdiction, and notice and suit must be directed to the governmental agency responsible for the roadway. Naming the wrong entity can permanently bar recovery.
• Preserving roadway defect evidence before repairs occur – Road surface depressions are often patched quickly, making early photographs, measurements, and location documentation critical to proving the defect existed and was dangerous.
• Ensuring statutory notice is timely and compliant – Michigan law requires notice as a condition to recovery, and that notice must specify “the exact location and nature of the defect.” (MCL 691.1404(1))
• Developing proof of causation and impact – Vehicle damage, repair records, crash reports, and expert analysis are often needed to establish that the road surface depression caused the loss of control or impact.
• Addressing governmental immunity defenses within statutory limits – Michigan law provides that “a governmental agency is immune from tort liability if the governmental agency is engaged in the exercise or discharge of a governmental function.” (MCL 691.1407(1)). A lawyer evaluates whether and how the highway exception applies.
• Protecting and maximizing No-Fault benefit recovery – No-Fault benefits are subject to strict filing deadlines, which limits recoverable losses if action is delayed.

Because road defect cases turn on statutory compliance as much as factual proof, experienced legal guidance is often essential to preserving and maximizing recovery.

Why choose the lawyers at Michigan Auto Law for my pothole car accident case?

Pothole cases are not routine car accident claims. They are statute-driven cases against government entities that are designed to be dismissed unless every legal requirement is met.

Michigan Auto Law is built for this kind of litigation. Our lawyers focus exclusively on serious motor vehicle cases and have decades of experience navigating governmental immunity, highway defect claims, and the procedural defenses that derail less-prepared cases.

Key reasons clients choose Michigan Auto Law for pothole car accident cases include:

• Deep experience with state governmental immunity law – Road defect claims rise or fall on immunity, statutory exceptions, and notice requirements. Our attorneys routinely handle cases involving governmental defendants and understand how courts apply these statutes in practice.
• Immediate investigation and evidence preservation – Roadway defects are often repaired quickly. We act immediately to document road surface depression size, depth, location, surrounding conditions, and vehicle damage before critical evidence disappears.
• Accurate jurisdiction and defendant identification – Determining which agency had jurisdiction over a roadway is essential. We know how to identify the correct city, county road agency, or state entity and ensure notice and litigation are directed properly from the start.
• Strict compliance with statutory notice requirements – Michigan law makes notice a condition to recovery in defective highway cases. Our lawyers ensure notice is timely, properly served, and contains the information required by statute, avoiding technical dismissals.
• Proven ability to litigate against government defenses – Government defendants often file early motions challenging notice, jurisdiction, and the applicability of the highway exception. We build cases with these defenses in mind and litigate aggressively when dismissal is attempted.
• Comprehensive handling of No-Fault benefits and tort claims – Michigan pothole car accident cases often involve overlapping No-Fault and third-party issues. We coordinate medical benefits, wage loss claims, and litigation strategy to protect the full scope of recovery available under Michigan law.
• A track record of results in complex auto cases – Michigan Auto Law has obtained significant verdicts and settlements in difficult, defense-driven cases. Our results reflect a firm that prepares cases thoroughly and is willing to take them to trial when necessary.
• Client-focused representation from start to finish – We limit caseloads, communicate clearly, and treat each case as unique. Clients work directly with experienced attorneys, not case managers.

Road defect cases demand precision, speed, and deep knowledge of Michigan law. Michigan Auto Law brings all three to every case we accept.

Injured In A Pothole Caused Car Accident In Michigan? Call Our Attorneys Now For A Free Consultation!

If you were injured in a pothole-related crash in Michigan and you have concerns and questions about your legal rights to pain and suffering compensation, economic damages and auto No-Fault insurance benefits, call now (800) 968-1001 for a free consultation with an experienced car accident lawyer. There is no cost or obligation. You can also visit our contact page or use the chat feature on our website.

Our law firm is the state’s largest and most successful law firm that specializes exclusively in helping people who have been injured in automobile crashes.

Our secret? Our attorneys deliberately handle fewer cases than other personal injury law firms.  This allows us to focus more time and attention on our cases.

Unlike other law firms, attorneys are never too busy to promptly return phone calls and answer questions. 

We have more than 3,000 5-Star reviews that reflect this care and attention to detail.

More importantly, this client-focused approach leads to better and faster settlements for our clients. We have recovered more million-dollar settlements and trial verdicts for motor vehicle crashes than any other lawyer or law firm in the state. We’ve also recovered the highest ever reported truck crash and auto crash settlement in the state.

Call now so we can start making a real difference for you.