Michigan Pothole Tire Damage Claim: How To Get Reimbursed

In Michigan, you may be able to get reimbursed for tire damage caused by a pothole, but recovery on your claim depends on who was responsible for the road, whether strict statutory requirements are met, and whether insurance coverage applies.

These requests for reimbursement involve a mix of government liability rules, insurance coverage decisions, evidence requirements, and tight deadlines. Reimbursement may come from a city, county, or state, from your own auto insurance, or, in limited cases, through a lawsuit.

A lawyer can help determine whether state or local government has jurisdiction over the road, whether a governmental claim is legally viable, how insurance coverage applies, and how to preserve key evidence before it disappears. 

Our law firm has decades of experience handling complex auto and road-defect cases. Our lawyers know how road defect requests for reimbursement actually work and how to protect drivers from losing valid requests on technical grounds.

Who is responsible for a pothole tire damage claim in Michigan?

Responsibility depends entirely on which governmental entity had jurisdiction over the roadway where the road defect was located. State law assigns maintenance duties based on road classification, not location alone.

In general: 

• Department of Transportation – Responsible for “state trunklines,” which are highways or freeways designated by an “I,” “US,” or “M” prefix (i.e., M-14, US-23, I-275)
• County road commissions – Responsible for most county roads outside city limits.
• Cities and villages – Responsible for locally maintained streets.

Identifying the correct agency is critical. Claims must be submitted to the entity with jurisdiction, and filing against the wrong one can permanently bar recovery.

How to get reimbursed for pothole tire damage in Michigan

In Michigan, to get reimbursed for pothole-related vehicle and tire damage, the most reliable method is through your car insurance. If you carry collision coverage or optional wheel and tire protection, your insurer may cover repairs or replacement after you pay your deductible. Liability-only policies do not cover damage to your own vehicle, so having the right coverage is essential. Be sure to document the damage with photos and obtain repair estimates to support your claim.

It is also possible to file a claim with the city, county, or state agency responsible for the road, but success is limited due to governmental immunity laws. Under the highway exception, a claim may proceed only if the roadway was not maintained in reasonable repair. Drivers must submit a formal claim within 120 days of the incident, including details such as the location of the road defect, the resulting vehicle damage, and any witnesses. Most agencies provide claim forms, but submitting one does not guarantee payment.

To succeed in a governmental claim, drivers generally must show that the road defect created a dangerous road condition, that the agency knew (or should have known) about it, and that the defect directly caused the vehicle damage. Because of the high bar set by governmental immunity, many claims are denied. MDOT notes on their website that “the majority of claims are denied under governmental immunity laws.”

It is also important to remember that road agencies — whether MDOT, a county road commission, or a city or village — are likely to only reimburse damage not already covered by insurance. For most drivers, filing a request for reimbursement through their own coverage remains the fastest and most practical way to be reimbursed.

Can I claim for pothole tire damage on my car insurance in Michigan?

In Michigan, you can claim pothole damage on your car insurance if you carry collision coverage or optional wheel and tire protection. These repair costs are typically treated as a collision claim, so your insurer may pay for repairs to your rims, wheels, suspension, or undercarriage after you meet your deductible. If you only carry liability coverage, your policy will not cover repairs to your own vehicle. Keep in mind that because these types of road defect vehicle repair claims are usually classified as an at-fault collision claim, filing one could affect your premiums. Before submitting a claim, compare your repair estimate to your deductible and consider asking your agent how it may impact your rates.

How to file an insurance claim for pothole tire damage in Michigan?

In Michigan, filing an insurance claim for pothole-related tire vehicle issues starts with documenting the damage and the road hazard, including photos and repair estimates. Only vehicles with collision coverage or optional wheel and tire protection are eligible, as liability-only policies don’t cover repairs. Contact your insurer promptly to provide details, submit estimates, and file the claim, which is usually treated as a collision loss. Your policy will cover repair costs minus your deductible, and staying in touch with your adjuster ensures the claim is processed smoothly.

Is it better to go through my insurance or file a claim with the city or county?

It depends on the amount of damage, your deductible, and how likely reimbursement is from the government entity.

Government claims are difficult to win and often denied. Insurance claims are faster but may increase premiums. In many cases, drivers pursue insurance first and explore reimbursement only if damage is substantial.

What kind of coverage applies – collision or comprehensive?

Pothole tire damage claims are almost always handled under collision coverage, not comprehensive coverage. The distinction matters because collision claims typically involve a deductible and may affect future insurance premiums, while comprehensive claims are treated differently under most policies.

In our state, collision coverage generally applies when a vehicle is damaged as a result of striking an object on the roadway or losing control due to road conditions. Because a road defect is part of the roadway surface and vehicle repairs result from direct impact, insurers routinely classify these claims as a collision loss, even though no other vehicle was involved.

Comprehensive coverage, by contrast, is typically limited to non-road hazards such as theft, vandalism, fire, falling objects, or animal strikes, and does not apply to road defect impacts.

This classification often surprises drivers, but it is consistent with how insurers interpret standard policy language. As a result, drivers pursuing insurance reimbursement for road defect vehicle repairs should expect the reimbursement request to be processed as a collision incident, subject to any applicable deductible and policy limits.

What is covered in a pothole tire damage claim in Michigan?

In Michigan, pothole damage is rarely limited to a flat tire. Depending on the size of the road hazard, how fast you hit it, and your vehicle type, a single roadway defect can lead to significant mechanical and structural issues.

Common types of repairs covered in a Michigan pothole tire damage claim may include:

• Tire repair – Blowouts, sidewall tears, and internal belt damage are among the most frequent pothole-related losses in Michigan and are often immediately apparent.
• Wheel and rim repair – Bent or cracked rims are common when impact occurs at speed and can require full replacement rather than repair.
• Suspension and steering repair – Control arms, struts, shocks, tie rods, and ball joints can all be damaged, sometimes without immediate symptoms.
• Alignment repair – Even when visible effects seem minor, road hazards often throw vehicles out of alignment, causing uneven wheel wear and steering or handling problems.
• Undercarriage repair – In severe cases, these types of road defects can impair oil pans, exhaust components, or protective underbody panels.

Coverage depends on demonstrating that the vehicle impairment resulted from the impact of the road defect and not from preexisting wear. Repair invoices, mechanic reports, and photographs are often critical to supporting the claim.

What evidence do I need to support my claim?

In Michigan, strong evidence is essential in any pothole tire damage claim, whether reimbursement is sought through insurance or directly from a governmental agency. Because potholes are often repaired quickly, documentation gathered immediately after the incident carries significant weight.

Key evidence typically includes:

• Photographs of the road defect – Images showing the size, depth, and location of the road defect, ideally with reference points such as lane markings, curbs, or nearby signage.
• Photographs of vehicle damage – Clear images of damaged wheels, suspension components, and undercarriage areas help establish the nature and extent of the loss.
• Location and timing information – Documentation showing where and when the damage occurred, including GPS data, dash-cam footage, or contemporaneous notes.
• Repair estimates and invoices – Written estimates and final repair bills from qualified repair facilities are essential to proving the cost and scope of damage.
• Mechanic or inspection reports – Statements confirming that the damage is consistent with the impact of the road defect can be particularly helpful when claims are disputed.
• Witness information, if available – Passengers or other drivers who observed the road defect or the impact may corroborate the claim.

Because missing or incomplete evidence is a common reason pothole tire damage claims are denied, gathering documentation as soon as possible after the incident can significantly improve the likelihood of reimbursement.

Are there limits on how much the city will pay for a pothole tire damage claim in Michigan?

There are limits on how much the city will pay, but they are not uniform across the state and depend on both the governmental entity involved and how the claim is pursued. Cities, counties, and the State often distinguish between smaller administrative claims and larger claims that must be resolved through litigation.

Some agencies will consider administrative reimbursement for relatively modest vehicle damage, while larger claims may require filing a lawsuit in the appropriate court. In practice, many Michigan governmental entities are reluctant to pay pothole tire damage claims at all and frequently deny them on immunity or notice grounds, regardless of the amount claimed. This is especially true when the agency contends it lacked notice of the defect or repaired it within a reasonable time.

Even when reimbursement is theoretically available, agencies often limit payment to actual repair costs supported by documentation and may exclude related expenses such as towing, rental vehicles, or incidental losses. 

It is important to keep in mind that the responsible road agency – especially the Michigan Department of Transportation – will only pay on a pothole damage claim for the tire and/or vehicle repair that is NOT covered by your insurance.

For these reasons, understanding how a particular city, county road agency, or MDOT handles road defect claims is critical before relying on government reimbursement as the sole recovery option.

Should I get repair estimates before I file my claim?

Repair estimates are a foundational part of any pothole tire damage claim and are often required before an insurance company or governmental agency will even evaluate the claim. Estimates help establish both the scope of damage and the amount being sought.

Obtaining one or more written estimates from qualified repair facilities serves several purposes. First, it documents that the damage is consistent with impact of the road defect rather than routine wear and tear. Second, it provides itemized costs that allow insurers or agencies to assess reasonableness. Third, it creates a contemporaneous record tying the damage to the incident, which can be important if the claim is disputed later.

In many cases, repair facilities will identify additional suspension, steering, or alignment damage that is not immediately visible. Submitting a claim without this information can result in underpayment or denial. For that reason, drivers are generally better positioned when they gather repair documentation before filing, even if the vehicle still appears drivable.

How long do I have to file a claim for pothole tire damage in Michigan?

The time frame for filing a pothole tire damage claim depends on who the claim is being made against and how recovery is sought. Insurance claims are governed by the terms of the auto insurance policy and should be reported as soon as reasonably possible after the damage occurs. Delays can lead to coverage disputes or denial.

Claims against governmental entities are more restrictive. Although property damage claims do not follow the same rules as personal injury cases, cities, counties, and MDOT often impose internal reporting deadlines and formal claim procedures. Missing these deadlines can result in automatic denial, regardless of the merits of the claim. When litigation is required, additional statutory deadlines apply, and failure to comply can bar recovery entirely.

Because Michigan pothole tire damage claims are highly procedural and vary by agency, drivers should act promptly, document the damage immediately, and determine which entity had jurisdiction over the roadway. Waiting too long can eliminate reimbursement options even when the damage itself is undisputed.

How long does a pothole tire damage claim take in Michigan?

In Michigan, the time it takes to resolve a pothole tire damage claim varies widely depending on how the claim is pursued and whether a governmental agency is involved. Claims handled solely through an auto insurance policy may be resolved relatively quickly, while claims against a city, county, or the State often take significantly longer.

Insurance claims for pothole tire damage in Michigan are usually evaluated once repair estimates, photographs, and proof of loss are submitted. If coverage is clear and the damage is undisputed, reimbursement may occur within weeks. Delays are more common when insurers dispute whether the damage resulted from the impact of the road defect or whether additional mechanical damage is related.

Claims against governmental entities typically take longer because agencies often review these types of claims cautiously and frequently deny them. Government defendants commonly investigate whether they had notice of the defect, whether the roadway met the legal standard for repair, and whether governmental immunity applies. If a request for reimbursement is denied and litigation is required, resolution may take many months or longer, particularly if the agency challenges jurisdiction, notice compliance, or the applicability of the highway exception.

Can you sue the city for pothole tire damage in Michigan?

In Michigan, you can sue a city or local government for pothole-related vehicle and tire damage, but success is limited by governmental immunity. To make a claim, you must show the municipality knew—or should have known—about the road defect, failed to repair it promptly, and caused repairs to your vehicle.

Before filing a lawsuit, you are usually required to submit a formal request for reimbursement to the city or county road agency. If the request for reimbursement is denied, you can pursue legal action in our state’s Court of Claims or local courts. Because small or routine repair requests for reimbursement are often denied, many drivers find it faster and more practical to use their collision coverage to cover vehicle-related repairs instead.

Pursuing a request for reimbursement against a governmental entity, however, involves additional legal requirements. State law generally grants cities and other governmental entities immunity from tort liability when they are performing governmental functions such as roadway maintenance, but there are exceptions that allow the governmental entity to be sued.

Our state’s governmental immunity statute provides that “a governmental agency is immune from tort liability if the governmental agency is engaged in the exercise or discharge of a governmental function.” (MCL 691.1407(1)). Because maintaining public roads is a governmental function, immunity applies unless a statutory exception removes it.

In Michigan, the primary exception that allows pothole tire and vehicle damage lawsuits is the highway exception. The law states that “each governmental agency having jurisdiction over a highway shall maintain the highway in reasonable repair so that it is reasonably safe and convenient for public travel.” (MCL 691.1402(1)). A lawsuit may proceed only if the claimant can show that the roadway failed to meet this statutory standard and that the defect caused the vehicle damage.

Even when the highway exception applies, state law imposes two strict time requirements:

1. You must be able to prove that the governmental entity either knew about or should have known about the road defect or that the road defect had been there for 30 days or longer – in which case it is presumed that the governmental entity knew about the road defect and had time to repair it. (MCL 691.1403) 
2. Within 120 days of your vehicle being damaged by a pothole in Michigan, you must serve notice on the responsible governmental entity of the vehicle and tire repair that occurred – which includes the location of the road defect, the repair(s) to your vehicle and the names of any witnesses. (MCL 691.1404(1))

Will the city pay for a pothole tire damage claim in Michigan?

In Michigan, cities rarely pay for pothole tire damage directly. Governmental immunity laws generally protect cities and other local agencies from liability when maintaining public roads. You can submit a request for reimbursement to the city or county road agency, but most small or routine repair requests are denied.

To succeed, you must typically prove that the city knew—or should have known—about the road defect, failed to repair it in a reasonable time, and that the road defect caused repairs to your vehicle. Even then, strict deadlines apply: notice must usually be given within 120 days of the incident, and the road defect must have existed long enough to presume the city had knowledge.

Because of these challenges, most drivers find it more practical to use collision coverage on their own insurance to pay for road defect-related repairs rather than relying on the city for reimbursement.

Do I need a lawyer to pursue a pothole tire damage claim against the city in Michigan?

In Michigan, many pothole tire and vehicle damage claims against cities fail not because the impact to the vehicle did not occur, but because statutory requirements were not met. Requests for compensation against governmental entities are governed by immunity rules, statutory exceptions, and notice requirements that do not apply to ordinary insurance requests.

An experienced lawyer can help determine whether governmental immunity applies and whether the highway exception may allow a request for reimbursement to proceed. As noted above, state law provides broad immunity for governmental agencies engaged in governmental functions. A lawyer evaluates whether the roadway condition falls within the statutory duty to maintain highways in reasonable repair.

Legal assistance is also critical for complying with notice requirements. State law makes notice a condition to any recovery in defective highway cases and requires that notice be timely and contain specific information. Missing the deadline or omitting required details can permanently bar recovery, regardless of the merits of the request for reimbursement.

Failure to satisfy the notice statute can block any attempt to seek reimbursement, even if the three-year limitations period has been met.

What is the statute of limitations for filing a lawsuit against a municipality for vehicle repairs caused by a road defect?

Lawsuits seeking reimbursement for pothole-related vehicle and tire repairs against a city, county, or the State of Michigan are governed by our state’s statute of limitations for property damage claims, along with additional statutory requirements that apply specifically to defective highway cases.

Under state law, an action to recover damages for injury to property must be filed within three years. The statute provides that “the period of limitations is 3 years after the time of the death or injury for all actions to recover damages for . . . injury to a person or property.” (MCL 600.5805(2)). This three-year period controls when a lawsuit must be commenced in court.

However, compliance with the statute of limitations alone is not sufficient in road defect cases. State law separately requires that statutory notice be served on the responsible governmental agency within 120 days of the road defect accident as a condition to recovery under the highway exception to governmental immunity. (MCL 691.1404(1)) The notice requirement is mandatory and applies even when a lawsuit is otherwise timely. Failure to satisfy the notice statute can bar a request for reimbursement regardless of compliance with the three-year limitations period.

Are there exceptions in a Michigan pothole tire damage claim if the road was recently inspected or the road defect was reported?

Governmental agencies frequently defend pothole tire damage claims in Michigan by showing that they lacked notice of the defect or that the roadway was inspected or repaired within a reasonable time. These defenses are closely tied to the statutory framework governing defective highway requests for reimbursement.

Our state’s highway exception imposes a duty on governmental agencies to maintain highways “in reasonable repair so that [they are] reasonably safe and convenient for public travel.” (MCL 691.1402(1)). Whether that duty was breached often turns on what the agency knew or should have known about the defect and how quickly it acted once aware of the condition.

Agencies may argue that a road defect developed recently, that it was not present long enough to establish notice, or that the roadway was inspected or repaired within a reasonable maintenance cycle. Evidence that a road defect was reported before the vehicle impairment occurred, that complaints were logged, or that the defect existed for an extended period can be critical in overcoming these defenses in a reimbursement request.

Because these issues are fact-driven and frequently disputed, documentation of prior reports, maintenance records, and the timing of inspections or repairs can significantly affect whether a pothole tire damage claim succeeds in Michigan.

Injured In A Car Accident? Call Our Attorneys Now For A Free Consultation!

If you were injured in a crash and you have concerns and questions about your legal rights to pain and suffering compensation, economic damages and auto No-Fault insurance benefits, call now (800) 968-1001 for a free consultation with an experienced car accident lawyer. There is no cost or obligation. You can also visit our contact page or use the chat feature on our website.

Our law firm is the state’s largest and most successful law firm that specializes exclusively in helping people who have been injured in auto accidents.

Our secret? Our car attorneys deliberately handle fewer cases than other personal injury law firms.  This allows us to focus more time and attention on our cases.

Unlike other law firms, attorneys are never too busy to promptly return phone calls and answer questions. 

We have more than 3,000 5-Star reviews that reflect this care and attention to detail.

More importantly, this client-focused approach leads to better and faster settlements for our clients. We have recovered more million-dollar settlements and trial verdicts for motor vehicle accidents than any other lawyer or law firm in the state. We’ve also recovered the highest ever reported truck accident and car crash settlement in the state.

Call now so we can start making a real difference for you.