Have you been injured? you may have a case. GET A FREE CONSULTATION

Complaints against Michigan’s auto insurance companies rise

September 25, 2013 by Steven M. Gursten

Farm Bureau, MEEMIC and Home-Owners saw greatest jumps in complaints in 2012 (no surprise there)

consumer complaints against MI auto insurance companies

If you’re a regular reader of this law blog, then no doubt the most recent data from Michigan’s Department of Financial and Insurance Services (DIFS) will come as little surprise:  Michigan’s auto insurance companies treat people very badly.  And complaints by consumers are on the rise.


In 2012, overall consumer complaints against Michigan auto insurers increased to 710 from 690 in 2011 and 660 in 2010, according to “Insurance Complaint Statistics” data released on June 27, 2013, by the Michigan Department of Financial and Insurance Services (DIFS).

As I’ve written previously, this is only the tip of the iceberg, as the vast majority of people mistreated by insurers never make complaints.  Michigan has R. Kevin Clinton as the state insurance commissioner, who was plucked from running an insure company.

On an individual-company basis, some of Michigan’s largest auto insurers saw significant increases in consumer complaints between 2011 and 2012:

  • Farm Bureau General Insurance Company of Michigan , 100% increase in consumer complaints
  • MEEMIC, 75% increase in consumer complaints
  • Home-Owners Insurance Company, 60% increase in consumer complaints
  • Auto-Owners Insurance Company, 30% increase in consumer complaints
  • Allstate Property and Casualty Insurance Company, 22% increase in consumer complaints

(See “Automobile” in the “Insurance Company Complaint Ratios” section of DIFS’s “Complaint Stats and Ratios” website page)

Sadly, the vast majority of insurance lawyers, myself included, regularly must tell people that it will be futile to file a complaint. Michigan has no bad faith laws, no punitive damages, and a consumer protection act that oddly enough has an exception to protecting consumers from insurance companies.

The rise in complaints gives us just a glimpse of how bad things are for people who have open No Fault claims with their own insurance companies.

Do you have any gripes with your auto insurance company? Share them by making a comment below, or by sounding off on our Michigan Auto Law Facebook page.

Related information:

Our attorney list of the worst auto insurance companies

Increasing profits at the expense of drivers: State Farm, Allstate and the McKinsey Report

[Community Guidelines]

One Reply to “Complaints against Michigan’s auto insurance companies rise”

  1. Where did my comment go about how saying that MEEMIC had a 75% increase in consumer complaints is misleading because the number went from 4 to 7?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts
Independent Medical Examination: Why They're No Laughing Matter
Independent Medical Examination (IME): Why They Are No Laughing Matter
April 15, 2020
Car insurance refund in the millions but insurers are saving billions
Car insurance refund in the millions but insurers are saving billions
April 13, 2020
Beware Of Progressive Insurance Settlement Offer
Progressive Insurance Settlement Offers To Beware Of
April 8, 2020