Sudden Emergency Defense - Michigan Auto Law®
Real Client Testimonials
Tonya's
Story
Text Us Call Us
What's My Case Worth
FREE Case Review

Excuses: The Sudden Emergency Defense

Have You Been Injured?

Get free legal advice today

Michigan lawyers handling automobile accident cases should be prepared for some very creative and unusual explanations from defendants as to how these motor vehicle accidents occur.  Sadly, far too many people believe that if they come up with an excuse, or blame the person who they hurt in the car accident, that it will be better for them.

Rarely is this the case.

Sudden Emergency Defense

The common excuse of people who cause accidents involves the “sudden emergency” defense doctrine.  In essence, the doctrine of sudden emergency says that when a defendant is confronted with such a “sudden emergency” that is “unusual or unsuspected” and the situation is not of his or her own making, and that the defendant is using ordinary care yet is not able to avoid the  collision that he sees and comprehends unfolding before him, his negligence can be excused.

What Must Defendants Show To Prove Sudden Emergency

The defendant must show that the sudden emergency was in view for a short length of time and the peril was totally unexpected. The sudden emergency defense must be raised by a defense lawyer as an affirmative defense to give notice before trial to the other side.

This doctrine has been raised by both honest and less than honest defendants involving everything from oil slicks, to sudden blinding sun, to sudden winter storm warnings, brake failure, child dart out, stalled cars, avoiding a prior accident and deer.

The plaintiff attorney handling automobile accident cases must focus on whether this sudden emergency was truly “not of his own making.”  Most defenses involving the sudden emergency doctrine can then be defeated by showing that the defendant did not use ordinary care in the moments that lead up to the defendant being confronted by a sudden emergency.

Steve M. Gursten,

Michigan Auto Law® Attorney - Bar#: P53632

Steven Gursten is an attorney and President of Michigan Auto Law®, specializing exclusively in Michigan No-Fault insurance, car, truck, motorcycle, and bus accident litigation, including catastrophic personal injury and traumatic brain injury (TBI) claims. Steven has secured the largest reported auto and truck accident settlements and trial verdicts of any attorney in Michigan. He is a Past President of the American Association for Justice (AAJ) Trucking and Traumatic Brain Injury Litigation Groups and has been named a Top 50 Michigan Super Lawyer, a Michigan "Go To Lawyer for Negligence Law" by Michigan Lawyers Weekly, and a Top Lawyer in Metro Detroit by DBusiness Magazine. He was recognized as "Lawyer of the Year" by The Best Lawyers in America® and received the Courage Award from The Melvin M. Belli Society for his advocacy against CURE Auto Insurance Company in Michigan.

Read Steven Gursten’s full attorney profile
Steve M. Gursten, Attorney

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. See our Community Guidelines.

Last updated:

How Much Is Your Michigan Auto Accident Case Worth?

Michigan Auto Law® is the leading and largest law firm in Michigan exclusively handling auto accident cases for more than 50 years. By answering a few simple questions we can help you determine how much your accident case could be worth

Find Out Now