Injured? Free Advice (800) 777-0028

Michigan Supreme Court backs down on attorney solicitation of personal injury and accident victims

Michigan accident attorney says waiting period should be at least 90 days and solicitation restrictions should apply to insurance companies and chiropractors, as well as injury lawyers

Bad news for accident victims. The Michigan Supreme Court looks like it’s backing off on the proposed rule to stop attorney solicitation of personal injury victims from being preyed upon after a car accident or truck accident. That’s unfortunate.

It’s distasteful, to say the least, for anyone to be in an auto accident and then to start getting letters and advertising materials from accident attorneys in the mail in the days that follow. Doesn’t help the professional reputation of lawyers. And frankly, most of the lawyers who are doing this are ones that injured accident victims would probably do well to stay away from.

But why single out the lawyers who are contacting people right after accidents? The insurance companies are starting to do this too. Adjusters and investigators are trying to settle potentially very significant claims, often for pennies on the dollar, by throwing in a few hundred dollars while negotiating mini-torts. And they are smart to do so, as the insurance industry says the average pain and suffering settlement that has a lawyer involved is on average, four times higher. And that’s the industry average, which includes a lot of lawyers who frankly probably bring down that average settlement amount.

But the ones I have the most disdain for are the “Michigan accident services” out there that are these quasi-medical-legal front organizations that are formed to specifically skirt the law on contacting injury and accident victims. They not only contact, but they call and call and call, and then investigators show up with lawyer information packages of lawyers that they funnel these cases to. Hey – insurance companies – you always claim fraud (even on the legitimate cases), why aren’t you investigating these groups?

What all these groups have in common is they fail the public trust. We are not protecting the public, but we are instead opening them up to be pounced upon like red meat by packs of dogs. Accident victims need to be made aware of their legal rights, and what they are entitled. They should be protected from all groups, not just some.

That’s why the Supreme Court’s announcement that it was re-evaluating the no solicitation for 30 days rule on July 19, 2011 is so troubling. Originally, the Michigan Supreme Court proposed two restrictions on attorneys’ ability to solicit legal business from personal injury victims. The Court suggested that accident attorneys be barred from soliciting victims in writing within 30 days of the victim’s accident. And, the court suggested that all written solicitations of business must include the words “advertising material.”

I originally applauded the Michigan Supreme Court for its proposed restrictions because they will go a long way to protecting personal injury victims and shutting down the predatory practices of unscrupulous “ambulance chasing” attorneys.

But there’s a lot more the justices need to do, assuming they do not back down here:

1. Implement a 90-day waiting period for attorneys’ written solicitations.

2. Impose restrictions on insurance companies’ “settlement solicitations.”

3. Extend the existing phone-solicitation ban to so-called “accident service agencies” and cold-calling doctors and law firm runners.

Why a 90-day waiting period for lawyers to contact car accident injury victims is better than nothing, but does not go far enough

The Michigan Supreme Court’s original proposal of a 30-day waiting period for attorneys’ written solicitations of business is commendable because it’s far better than the status quo: nothing. No waiting period.

But a 90-day waiting period is still better. Many injuries are just beginning to be uncovered, or are initially masked by strong narcotic pain medications. Many traumatic brain injuries, especially from car accidents, take several months to first be documented.

A 90-day waiting period would provide personal injury victims with greater privacy and protection from unsolicited intrusion. And by making timing less of an issue, it may discourage lawyers from the shameful practice of using the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) to request police/accident reports and, then, sending solicitation letters to the accident victims identified in the reports.

Insurance company ‘settlement solicitations’

All of the existing and proposed restrictions on attorney solicitations should apply with equal, if not greater, force to insurance companies’ “settlement solicitations.”

In fact, the Michigan Supreme Court’s rationale for restricting attorney solicitations makes just as much sense when applied to insurance company “settlement solicitations” (substituting “insurance company” for “lawyer”):

There is a potential for abuse inherent in direct contact by [an insurance company] with a prospective client known to need legal services. These forms of contact between [an insurance company] and a prospective client subject the layperson to the private importuning of the trained advocate in a direct interpersonal encounter. The prospective client, who may already feel overwhelmed by the circumstances giving rise to the need for legal services, may find it difficult to evaluate fully all available alternatives with reasoned judgment and appropriate self-interest in the face of the [insurance company’s] presence and insistence upon [settling the claim] immediately. The situation is fraught with the possibility of undue influence, intimidation, and overreaching.” (Comment to Rule 7.3 of the Michigan Rules of Professional Conduct)

Insurance company “settlement solicitations” occur when an insurance company “closer” ambushes the personal injury victim at his or her home within hours of or the next day after the accident and tries to “solicit” a quick, low-ball settlement before the victim hires an attorney.

Insurance companies know that victims with experienced attorneys settle claims for four times as much as victims without lawyers.

Accident attorneys shouldn’t be the only ones barred from phone solicitations

Accident attorneys should not be the only ones banned from using the telephone to solicit legal business from personal injury victims.

The phone-solicitation restriction, under both the existing and proposed restrictions in and to Rule 7.3 of the Michigan Rules of Professional Conduct, should also apply to phony “accident service agencies,” which are really just people paid by law firms to steer prospective clients to the law firm.

Additionally, the phone-solicitation restrictions should also be extended to physicians. Shockingly, I’m hearing with increasing frequency from clients about cold-calls they have received at home or in the hospital from doctors, especially chiropractors.

Let’s do more

Again, the Michigan Supreme Court’s initial proposed restrictions on contacting personal injury victims are laudable. I hope they do not back down from this as they “re-evaluate” this rule.

But instead of allowing those restrictions to be the final word, let’s treat them as the beginning of the bigger discussion on how we as the bar can best protect the public. We are not in the business of law. We are a profession in the business of protecting the public. Let’s bring true protection to Michigan personal injury victims.

Steve Gursten is one of the nation’s top accident attorneys. He is head of Michigan Auto Law and has received the highest verdict in the state for a car accident or truck accident victim in 2008, 2009 and 2010, according to Michigan Lawyers Weekly.

Related Information:

New rule curbs lawyer solicitation letters in Michigan

Let’s stop predatory auto insurance company solicitation of car accident victims too

Protecting the public from attorney solicitation phone calls and letters

Michigan Auto Law is the largest law firm exclusively handling car accident, truck accident and motorcycle accident cases throughout the entire state. We have offices in Farmington Hills, Detroit, Ann Arbor, Grand Rapids and Sterling Heights to better serve you. Call (800) 777-0028 for a free consultation with one of our accident attorneys.

This entry was tagged Tags: , , , ,
Community Guidelines
comments powered by Disqus
Blog Author Steven M. Gursten
Read Our Reviews
Free Consultation