Call Today (888) 369-5909

Tag Archives: Michigan Supreme Court

Is the Michigan Supreme Court biased in favor of insurance companies, against consumers and the injured?

New CPAN study shows auto insurers won 84% of major No Fault cases before Michigan’s highest court in last 10 years

MSC biased in favor of insurance companies

Attorneys who represent auto accident victims in this state have long suspected  that the deck is stacked against their clients  when they take their case before the Michigan Supreme Court.

Those suspicions are now confirmed, according to an excellent and timely new study by the Coalition Protecting Auto No-Fault (CPAN),  “Analysis of Michigan Supreme Court cases decided under the Michigan No-Fault Act within the past 10 years.”

Significantly, here’s what CPAN found:

Posted in Car Insurance, Michigan Case Law, No Fault Reform | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Michigan Supreme Court’s No Fault ruling denies wheelchair van for motorcycle accident victim

Majority misapplies its own rule to deny van for catastrophically injured auto accident victim in Admire v. Auto Owners

Michigan Supreme Court denies wheelchair van in Admire v. Auto Owners

The past 10 years have certainly left experienced No Fault lawyers increasingly puzzled by the “bizzaro” world that the Michigan Supreme Court seems to inhabit whenever it interprets Michigan’s No Fault Law.  Whether that be its own incredibly activist interpretation of a plain, unambiguous statutory definition of serious impairment in Kreiner, to the dreadful Cameron decision to Johnson v. Recca, the lawyers who practice in this area of law have largely adopted a “what’s next?” attitude while waiting for the next decision to come.

Posted in Car Insurance, Michigan Case Law, No Fault Reform | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Former justice expose: Michigan Supreme Court is beholden to secretive special interests

Ex Justice Elizabeth Weaver says current Court is guilty of partisanship in her new book, Judicial Deceit: Tyranny and Unnecessary Secrecy at the Michigan Supreme Court

Elizabeth Weaver, former Michigan Supreme Court Justice

Elizabeth Weaver, former Michigan Supreme Court Justice

For the past decade, the Michigan Supreme Court has devastated the rights of car accident victims. I’ve written at length about legal decisions such as Kreiner, Cameron and Devillers — and recently a slew of decisions that decimate an injury victim’s access to life-saving No Fault insurance benefits — that are destroying the fundamental principles underlying our No Fault law.

Posted in Car Accidents, Michigan Case Law | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Michigan Supreme Court contradicts itself on No Fault ‘causation’

No Fault attorney highlights Court’s contradictions in recent opinion on  No Fault causation in McPherson v. McPherson

In a frustrating, bewildering and confounding opinion in McPherson v. McPherson, the Michigan Supreme Court contradicted itself on the proper definition of No Fault causation, specifically about whether Ian McPherson’s spinal cord injury was caused by his motor vehicle accident.

On the one hand, the Supreme Court majority – comprised of the court’s four  Republican justices but also the recently-elected Democratic justice Bridget Mary McCormack – concluded that the “causal connection” between Mr. McPherson’s injury and his accident was “insufficient” and, thus, the majority denied his claim for No Fault benefits.

Posted in Car Insurance, No Fault Reform | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

The perfect storm: Republicans to control Michigan Supreme Court for a long, long time to come

Justice Diane HathawayTo be clear, I have nothing against Republicans.  On many issues, I am one.  But I do have something against activist judges and justices who ignore settled law to follow an extreme political agenda.

Michigan saw that happen during the previous “Gang of Four” era.  These four Engler appointees not only took control of the Court, but they caused so many lawyers and judges to lose faith in our civil justice system.  As Justice Stevens observed in his dissent in the Citizens United case:  “A democracy cannot function effectively when its constituent members believe laws are being bought and sold.” Citizens United v. FEC, 130 S. Ct. 876, 954 (2010) (Stevens, J., dissenting).  The way our highest Court ruled consistently against individual citizens and for the insurance industry, dismantling entire areas of consumer protection and personal injury law in its wake was and remains shocking.

Posted in Car Accidents, Michigan Case Law | Tagged | Leave a comment

Preserving the integrity of the judicial branch

A guest blog post from Michigan Supreme Court candidate Bridget Mary McCormack

As my readers and friends know, I have strongly endorsed Bridget Mary McCormack for the Michigan Supreme Court.   Professor McCormack was also endorsed by the New York Times on November 1,  and she represents a bright hope to preserving the integrity of the Michigan Supreme Court.

Posted in Car Insurance | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Video: Michigan Supreme Court’s biased record of favoring insurance companies over consumers

Justices Markman and Zahra have failed to protect injured auto accident victims 100 percent of the time

The Republican majority of our Michigan Supreme Court  has sided with insurance companies — and against consumers, including seriously injured auto accident victims — 100% of the time.

Take a look:

As the video says, our current Justices Stephen Markman and Brian Zahra have sided with insurance companies over people 100 percent of the time under Michigan’s No-Fault law. And Republican candidate and former insurance industry lawyer Colleen O’Brien isn’t any better.  She actually worked to deny benefits to a cancer patient.

Posted in Car Accidents, Michigan Case Law | Tagged | Leave a comment

Michigan Supreme Court issues new rules for No-Fault attendant care compensation

Important attendant care warning on Douglas v. Allstate for family member providers, those recovering attendant care

On July 30, 2012, in Douglas v. Allstate Insurance Company, the Michigan Supreme Court issued new rules for when an auto accident victim’s family member can be compensated for providing attendant care services to the victim.  This decision will have a huge impact for people who currently receive attendant care No-Fault benefits from their auto insurance company, and changes the rules in mid-stream for attendant care lawyers on how submittals must be made.

Posted in Car Insurance, No Fault Reform | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Form over substance reigns supreme on the Michigan Supreme Court

Auto accident and bus accident victims denied their day in court, 7th Amendment right by activist Republican Court

Form over substance. Technicalities over justice.  Politics over precedent. Insurance company or corporation over an individual citizen.

Our four activist Republican justices on the Michigan Supreme Court have once again proved that form over substance reigns supreme in this state, especially when it means that an injured, innocent person loses to an insurance company or corporation, “form over substance” is a fitting description of the judicial philosophy for our state’s highest court.

Posted in Car Insurance, No Fault Reform | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Tea Party should vote against Chief Justice Robert Young for the Michigan Supreme Court

Partisan, wildly activist, rabidly pro-insurance and anti-consumer defines Justice Young’s record on Court

Shouldn’t Justice Robert P. Young, Jr. be the anti-Tea Party candidate for the Michigan Supreme Court this November? Then how ironic that Justice Robert Young is now attempting to portray himself as standing for the principles of the Tea Party movement before the upcoming election.

If they only knew about the real Justice Young.

There’s a lot I liked about the original Tea Party. Not the one that has lately been kidnapped by Karl Rove, Roger Ailes, and the corporate establishment, but the original grass roots movement. Chief among those admirable qualities was that the tea party seeks to represent ordinary Americans in a world where both political parties seem kidnapped by special interests.

Posted in Driver Safety, Michigan Case Law | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment